Connection speed and web design

Eventually there may come a day when everyone on the planet has access to the best internet connection speed possible. For now, however, there are still people in highly developed nations (such as, say, the U.S.) who are dealing with dial-up speeds and computers that should have long been obsolete.

This is the reality of technological advancement. Unfortunately, it’s an easy thing to forget for web developers who consider technology a priority.

When you make it a point to find the best possible speeds from your ISP, the latest computer, and state of the art software, it becomes increasingly difficult to imagine that your customers may be using less. In some cases, much less. And this divide can make for some very poor web design choices.

 

User frustration

According to a 1998 Georgia Tech survey of web users, the biggest problem people had when surfing the internet was speed. In fact, “speed” alone was only below “slow ads” when it came to the largest response percentage. And both of those concepts can be folded into the speed category, as few users are likely to be frustrated because they can’t see their favorite ads in time.

Rather, they are frustrated because the page loads the ad before the content, forcing them to wait even longer before getting to the good stuff. While slow loading ads are not nearly as prevalent 14 years later and internet speeds in general have improved a great deal, technology has moved forward as well. It might take a modern computer and decent connection only a fraction of a second to load a Geocities page from 1998. The results, however, may not be that different when you compare apples-with-apples.

Rural America

 

Modern design

Modern web design techniques have come a long way from the animated .gifs and sparkly graphics that littered the Web in the mid-90s. While few would argue that today’s internet is not more attractive for the changes, the programs and design choices of today’s web designers are often meant to take advantage of powerful computers and—perhaps more importantly—high speed connections.

But look at some of the most popular sites. Facebook. Reddit. Google. These sites are visited by millions a day, are structurally and graphically sound (if not outrageously beautiful), and they get few complaints from users on slow connections. Each of these sites keeps the focus on providing a streamlined service for their users.

With design trends already leaning towards minimalism, it shouldn’t be too much of a challenge to go and do the same. Unfortunately, that desire to push technological capabilities just a bit further can sometimes lead to questionable choices.

Rural America

 

Increasing user speed

In an analysis of usability and computer speed, the University of Maryland’s Necip Fazil Ayan came up with some recommendations for web designers. Chief among these recommendations was this golden rule: “Make Your Pages As Fast As Possible”. Simple, direct, and as true today as it was in the early days of the internet.

To accomplish this goal, Ayan advised a three pronged approach: make your pages load quickly, make them display quickly, and make them easily navigable. But this brings us back to our primary consideration; what is fast and easy to navigate on state of the art satellite internet could very well be a nightmare for someone whose ISP hasn’t gotten around to providing DSL. To make sure your web designs can reach your target audience, you need to know what that audience is. And if your pages are designed for a broad demographic, you still need to develop with the lowest common denominator in mind.

 

The reality of the situation

It is easy to become so entrenched in your surroundings that you forget that not everyone has it so good. Six months after buying your first HDTV, did it seem inconceivable that anyone was still watching a boxy, standard definition television? Never mind the fact that you still had one in your bedroom. If you traded in physical CDs for the convenience of MP3s a long time ago, it may seem improbable that anyone is still buying them.

But 2011 was the first year in history that digital sales outdid physical ones in the music industry, and then, only by a hair. There are still a lot of people out there using and buying CDs.

Rural America

Of course, all of this is just to illustrate how the universal adoption of new technology is not always up to speed with the actual rate at which said technology comes out. Perhaps nowhere is this disparity clearer than in the realm of connection speeds.

Here, customers are not only limited by their own budgets, but by what is offered in their area. According to a Speed Matters 2010 report on American Internet speeds, a full 49% of American households were below the FCC’s minimum broadband speed standard, which stood at 4 megabits per second for download rates. While we like to think of the U.S. as the leader (or at least near the top) when it comes to technology and progress, we managed to rank a dismal 25th when it came to average connection speeds when compared with other countries.

 

Designing to speed

The size of the average website grew seven times larger between 2003 and 2011. This trend continues today, optimizing the browsing experience for those with state of the art, broadband connections, but leaving those on weaker connections left to browse Facebook and do little more.

Reach out to these people when you do your website design. If you’re designing a website for those who may still be using 56k modems, a page full of videos, graphics and intense JavaScript isn’t going to fly. These pages may look good in your portfolio, but they are going to cause many users to hit the back button.

 

Compromise

Of course, there are those designers who simply say, “Too bad,” and move on. It’s not up to them, they exclaim, to make sure every hillbilly on an Apple IIc can access their site.

For those targeting high end clientele or technologically savvy readers, this may well be an acceptable point of view. However, if you goal is to reach those users in rural America or those in countries where high speed internet is but a dream, you’ll need to temper your excitement for the future. Take an HTML tag down here and there. Remove an image or two. Find a low speed connection and give your website a whirl. You may find that optimization and design can work for both those on satellite internet and those on dusty dial-up modems.

0 shares
  • http://www.facebook.com/themadpoetuk Elliott Rodgers

    Some good points. Is it maybe time for Browsers to include a speed in their user agent string?

    Should web developers include within “responsive design” allowances for connection speed?

    • http://www.blackbookoperations.com/ Black Book Operations

      I asked myself the very same question… do we have to integrate “flexibility” on the connection speed differences… or pop up a message for users with a slow connection to view everything “text-based” or … After all… it is getting quite complex already. (I might be tempted to attach code, made for smartphones to the code needed for slow internet connections…)

    • http://www.blackbookoperations.com/ Black Book Operations

      I asked myself the very same question… do we have to integrate “flexibility” on the connection speed differences… or pop up a message for users with a slow connection to view everything “text-based” or … After all… it is getting quite complex already. (I might be tempted to attach code, made for smartphones to the code needed for slow internet connections…)

  • http://sourcecanvas.com/ Source Canvas

    What a fantastic written piece explaining how the web design process can work. Expedient projects are often the designs where you learn the most in the shortest amount of time.

  • http://www.audiomind.us/blog AUDIOMIND

    1998 survey? Speed is important, but the number of users using broadband internet in 2012 has risen dramatically since the 90s. In the US, less than 3 million customers have dialup and the number is steadily declining. The focus has now turned to mobile.

  • Davide Tampellini

    just a little off topic, but… my avast said there was a malware in this page, in jquery.fancybox.php …
    maybe you should take a look at it…

  • http://www.jtechcommunications.com/ JTech

    Page load speed is a top factor in our website design process. We optimize all design element factors for speed to accommodate the best user experience for their connection. 

  • http://twitter.com/TechArun_Net Arun Godwin

    Nice article and you have explained it perfectly about the internet revolutionary on speed. In India many users are still using the dial-up connection but young generation switched over to the Mobile Technology. The aim is for 2020 where most of the people will have 3G or 4G connection and share the information quickly as possible.