Do we really need another HTML5 authoring app?

Wdd Logo.
October 01, 2013
Do we really need another HTML5 authoring app?.

thumbnailYesterday Google released the beta version of its newest project: Web Designer.

Announced earlier this year, Web Designer is a visual tool for building HTML5 adverts; although one suspects Google's ambitions for the application are much wider, given that it's not named 'Google Ad Builder'.

Web Designer is, at first glance, a promising piece of software, but I question whether we really need yet another tool for building HTML5 content.

All HTML5 applications — and there are already some great apps for coding HTML5, Hype for example — create an environment in which we, as designers, are separated from the source code that we're working with; there is always an extra layer between us. It's true that most tools — including Google Web Designer — allow you to edit code with a built-in editor of some kind, but in my experience good coding practices are usually sidelined when a deadline is looming and it's simply faster to drag and drop.

If we want a truly open, standards-compliant web, don't we need to learn the underlying technologies for ourselves? Is HTML5 really so complex that we can't learn it? Is CSS3 so difficult to master we'd rather tweak a properties panel?

The creation of these tools, from Apple's iAd to Google's Web Designer has been enabled by the collapse of the Flash industry. According to Google there are already more HTML5-capable devices than Flash-capable devices (which makes sense given the iPhone's nonplussed reaction to SWF files) and the market is expected to grow by over 40% by the end of the year. In fact the only surprising thing is that the market isn't growing faster and that any Flash content is still produced at all.

However whilst Adobe have apparently sought to distance themselves from Flash (Adobe Edge Animate does not feel like a Flash interface), Google have no such compunction, and Web Designer has a distinctly Flash MX 2004 feel about it.

How much of Web Designer is new and how much is, as suggested by certain sources, simply a fork of the Motorola Mobility project Ninja (which Google now own) is difficult to say without looking under the hood. What we can be sure of is that whatever its origins, Web Designer is a natural step for Google, it makes absolute sense that having cornered the market in advertising, Google should produce a tool for building those adverts. Already tied into DoubleClick and AdMob, the option to publish for other networks is included, but is unlikely to be widely used.


Déjà vu for Actionscript programmers.

Probably the biggest blow to Adobe, and to all rival applications is that Google Web Designer is free, at least for now. It's very hard to justify a Flash CC subscription when there's a free alternative — albeit one that is a little more basic. Google has beaten Microsoft office into submission by delivering basic rivals free of charge, why not Adobe CC too?

In many ways Google Web Designer is inventing a role for itself. But whilst it's free, is there any chance it won't be successful? And if it is extended over the next year or two to include full site builds, will it reach the stage of replacing an in-depth knowledge of HTML5? It will be bad news for the Web if it does.

Have you downloaded Google Web Designer yet? Do you think Google will expand its remit in the near future? Let us know in the comments.

WDD Staff

WDD staff are proud to be able to bring you this daily blog about web design and development. If there's something you think we should be talking about let us know @DesignerDepot.

Popular Posts

Read Next

Exciting New Tools for Designers, November 2023

We’ve got a mix of handy image helpers, useful design assets, and clever productivity tools, amongst other treats. Some…

The Dangers of Doomscrolling for Designers and How to Break Free

As a creative professional, navigating the digital realm is second nature to you. It’s normal to follow an endless…

From Image Adjustments to AI: Photoshop Through the Years

Remember when Merriam-Webster added Photoshop to the dictionary back in 2008? Want to learn how AI is changing design…

3 Essential Design Trends, November 2023

In the season of giving thanks, we often think of comfort and tradition. These are common themes with each of our three…

30 Obsolete Technologies that will Perplex Post-2000s Kids

Remember the screech of dial-up internet? Hold fond memories of arcade machines? In this list, we’re condensing down 30…

15 Best New Fonts, October 2023

We’re entering the final quarter of 2023, and even in the pre-holiday lull, there are still plenty of fonts to get…

Progressive Web Apps (PWAs): Unlocking The Future of Mobile-First Web Development

There are over 5.4 billion mobile users today, meaning that over 68% of the population tap into an online business via…

The 12 Most Controversial Ad Campaigns of the 21st Century

How far would an organization be willing to go for the chance to generate a little extra buzz? In this list, we're…

20 Best New Websites, October 2023

The Bento trend is still going strong: In some cases, we see this extend to the layout, but many more are picking…

Exciting New Tools for Designers, October 2023

This month, we have a whole bag of goodies for designers, developers, and designevelopers alike. (Yes, we did just make…

The 10 Most Successful Rebrands of All Time - Ranked

We’re all familiar with rebrands going wrong, but what happens when they go right? From McDonald’s health kick to…

3 Essential Design Trends, October 2023

Every now and then, website design trends can leave you scratching your head. This month’s collection includes some of…