The 2 biggest questions about the Target redesign

Wdd Logo.
December 31, 2013
The 2 biggest questions about the Target redesign.

thumbnailThe dust hasn’t settled on the new Target.com redesign: the Web (OK, well, the web design community and a few actual Target customers) are looking for answers:

  1. Why, Target? Why?
  2. Who is responsible?

The first question may be a little easier to address, since Target has now responded to the criticism. They insist the redesign is based on pre-launch testing and positive post-launch traffic and sales, and promise to keep making adjustments as they learn more. Connections are also being drawn to the end of Target’s reliance on the Amazon website platform.

The answer to the second question is more of a closely-guarded secret. AdFreak checked in with some notable digital agencies known to be working with Target (Olson, SapientNitro, Huge, Razorfish), and all denied involvement. According to AdFreak, some said they believed the redesign was handled in-house.

target

An interesting comment on the Jezebel website by a friend of a past Target employee is a little chilling. Admittedly, we don’t know the full story behind why someone in management would address improvement suggestions by telling the designer, “not to bother.” Still, anyone with corporate experience is probably reading these words with a mixture of bitterness and resignation. In fairness to Target’s in-house team, the mess probably has more to do with pressure from above.

While it’s pragmatic to stop at, “this was tested: this is what worked.” It’s just as practical to recognize that testing still needs to be coupled with basic, purposeful design principles. Target in particular has been setting itself apart from the other big box stores for years with its emphasis on better design. In that light, this can also be considered a failure beyond visual identity, to brand.

In case you were curious, in an AdFreak follow-up piece, Target Defends Homepage Redesign but Still Won't Say Who Did It.

Writers aren’t too happy about the whole Big Red Periods thing, either.

Are you responsible for the Target.com redesign? Would you admit it if you were? Let us know in the comments.

WDD Staff

WDD staff are proud to be able to bring you this daily blog about web design and development. If there's something you think we should be talking about let us know @DesignerDepot.

Read Next

Exciting New Tools for Designers, October 2023

This month, we have a whole bag of goodies for designers, developers, and designevelopers alike. (Yes, we did just make…

The 10 Most Successful Rebrands of All Time - Ranked

We’re all familiar with rebrands going wrong, but what happens when they go right? From McDonald’s health kick to…

3 Essential Design Trends, October 2023

Every now and then, website design trends can leave you scratching your head. This month’s collection includes some of…

Weekly Design News #2

Every Sunday, we round up the best stories from webdesignernews.com. This issue features UX principles to improve your…

24 Best Creative Portfolio Websites in 2023

For anyone working in a digital creative field, whether design, illustration, animation, video, or a combination of…

15 Best New Fonts, September 2023

Nothing upgrades your designs like selecting the right font. It’s all too easy to fall into the trap of using the same…

Weekly Design News #1

Every Sunday we’re rounding up the best of the previous week’s stories from webdesignernews.com, and in this issue #1,…

The 20 Most Controversial Logos of All Time (Ranked)

When you hire graphic designers to create your company's logo, what do you expect? Professional designs, culturally…

LimeWire AI Studio Generative Art App

If you’re looking for the most exciting way to launch a career in AI-generated art, then you’re in the right place.

20 Best New Websites, September 2023

Are you in need of design inspiration? Are you looking for the best websites designed in 2023 to pull ideas,…

The Dangers of Deceptive Design Patterns (And How to Avoid Them)

As web designers, our role in crafting user-friendly digital landscapes is critical. We are tasked with creating user…

10 Best Ecommerce WordPress Themes in 2023 [September update]

You plan to set up shop with an online store. You know there’ll be competition. And to compete with or beat that…